Welcome to the AppalachianTrailCafe.net!
Take a moment and register and then join the conversation
Take a moment and register and then join the conversation
What is this???
This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site, you are agreeing to our Cookie Policy.
-
-
My first thought was Mountain Ash but I'm not sure. Another Kevin is good with id'ing plants, I think he will know.Lost in the right direction.
-
TrafficJam wrote:
My first thought was Mountain Ash but I'm not sure. Another Kevin is good with id'ing plants, I think he will know.
Holding out hope it's 'Seng ...1 Fish, 2 Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish... -
Not a Mountain Ash - the leaves are all wrong for that. American Crabapple (Malus coronaria) maybe? It doesn't look nearly prickly enough to be any of the sixty or so species of hawthorn that live in Pennsylvania - if it's got wicked thorns that I'm not seeing, one of those would be my guess. The invasive Bradford pear [Pyrus calleryana] also has nasty thorns, and would be a possibility if it's a problem species locally.I'm not lost. I know where I am. I'm right here.
-
AnotherKevin wrote:
Not a Mountain Ash - the leaves are all wrong for that. American Crabapple (Malus coronaria) maybe? It doesn't look nearly prickly enough to be any of the sixty or so species of hawthorn that live in Pennsylvania - if it's got wicked thorns that I'm not seeing, one of those would be my guess. The invasive Bradford pear [Pyrus calleryana] also has nasty thorns, and would be a possibility if it's a problem species locally.
There were no thorns at all AK... When I saw it from a distance, my initial thought was "Dahoon(SP) Holly" that I used to see in Florida, but the leaves are kinda serrated, and not thick like I remember... Bark is all wrong to be a Malus coronaria...1 Fish, 2 Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish... -
Toli wrote:
AnotherKevin wrote:
Not a Mountain Ash - the leaves are all wrong for that. American Crabapple (Malus coronaria) maybe? It doesn't look nearly prickly enough to be any of the sixty or so species of hawthorn that live in Pennsylvania - if it's got wicked thorns that I'm not seeing, one of those would be my guess. The invasive Bradford pear [Pyrus calleryana] also has nasty thorns, and would be a possibility if it's a problem species locally.
There were no thorns at all AK... When I saw it from a distance, my initial thought was "Dahoon(SP) Holly" that I used to see in Florida, but the leaves are kinda serrated, and not thick like I remember... Bark is all wrong to be a Malus coronaria...
My first guess was either this or the Brazilian pepper tree (Florida Holly) but that serrated edge is what makes it look different.
The berries all strung out and not in a cluster is different too.
Changes Daily→ ♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫ ♪♫♪♫♪♫ ← Don't blame me. It's That Lonesome Guitar. -
milkman wrote:
Toli wrote:
AnotherKevin wrote:
Not a Mountain Ash - the leaves are all wrong for that. American Crabapple (Malus coronaria) maybe? It doesn't look nearly prickly enough to be any of the sixty or so species of hawthorn that live in Pennsylvania - if it's got wicked thorns that I'm not seeing, one of those would be my guess. The invasive Bradford pear [Pyrus calleryana] also has nasty thorns, and would be a possibility if it's a problem species locally.
There were no thorns at all AK... When I saw it from a distance, my initial thought was "Dahoon(SP) Holly" that I used to see in Florida, but the leaves are kinda serrated, and not thick like I remember... Bark is all wrong to be a Malus coronaria...
My first guess was either this or the Brazilian pepper tree (Florida Holly) but that serrated edge is what makes it look different.
The berries all strung out and not in a cluster is different too.
I forgot all aboot Brazilian Pepper... When I was building Golf Course's in Florida and we were clearing land, we would douse huge stands of them with fuel and burn them first... They were EXTREMLY invasive back then ...1 Fish, 2 Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish... -
Toli wrote:
milkman wrote:
Toli wrote:
AnotherKevin wrote:
Not a Mountain Ash - the leaves are all wrong for that. American Crabapple (Malus coronaria) maybe? It doesn't look nearly prickly enough to be any of the sixty or so species of hawthorn that live in Pennsylvania - if it's got wicked thorns that I'm not seeing, one of those would be my guess. The invasive Bradford pear [Pyrus calleryana] also has nasty thorns, and would be a possibility if it's a problem species locally.
There were no thorns at all AK... When I saw it from a distance, my initial thought was "Dahoon(SP) Holly" that I used to see in Florida, but the leaves are kinda serrated, and not thick like I remember... Bark is all wrong to be a Malus coronaria...
My first guess was either this or the Brazilian pepper tree (Florida Holly) but that serrated edge is what makes it look different.
The berries all strung out and not in a cluster is different too.
I forgot all aboot Brazilian Pepper... When I was building Golf Course's in Florida and we were clearing land, we would douse huge stands of them with fuel and burn them first... They were EXTREMLY invasive back then ...
You can't kill that stuff. It's gotta be pulled up by the root. Even then, if you leave the tiniest of a sprig it'll be a bush in a year and a tree in two. They want that stuff out of there. Kills everything it touches.Changes Daily→ ♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫ ♪♫♪♫♪♫ ← Don't blame me. It's That Lonesome Guitar. -
-
Rasty wrote:
Doesn't look like ginseng. There berries are not in clusters.
Thanks Captain BuzzKill... There goes my retirement fund ...1 Fish, 2 Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish... -
Brazilian pepper won't survive a Pennsylvania winter!
There are thornless hawthorns also, so my next guess might be Crataegus punctata. But I'm going way beyond where I'm comfortable being able to make an identification without a better look at it.I'm not lost. I know where I am. I'm right here. -
-
Drybones wrote:
It's a bush with red berries.
Thanks for clearing that up, that was my gut instinct ...1 Fish, 2 Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish... -
-
Share
- Facebook 0
- Twitter 0
- Google Plus 0
- Reddit 0